White Christian progressives might be nationalists too, ecumenical panel says

(RNS) — Whereas evangelicals are the group most frequently criticized for equating American identification with adherence to Christianity, white progressive Christians have work to do to handle their very own Christian nationalism, consultants mentioned at an ecumenical gathering this week.

“It’s very simple to take a look at (Donald) Trump, to take a look at Trump’s followers, to take a look at Jan. 6 and say, ‘That is white nationalism. That is unhealthy,’” Miguel De La Torre, professor of social ethics and Latinx research at Iliff Faculty of Theology, mentioned through the Christian Unity Gathering of the Nationwide Council of Church buildings on Tuesday (Oct. 12). “Liberal Christians are simply as complicit with white nationalism that the Trumpites had been that we noticed on Jan. 6.”

De La Torre, writer of “Decolonizing Christianity,” was considered one of a number of audio system on a panel inspecting Christian nationalism on the two-day digital gathering. Clergy, students and authors mentioned spiritual leaders needed to reply for his or her relative silence and lack of motion after insurrectionists stormed the U.S. Capitol. 

“Once we noticed that riot, and we noticed the cross and a hangman’s noose facet by facet, there ought to have been an enormous hue and cry all through the nation, all through the nation by Christian leaders,” mentioned the Rev. Obery Hendricks, a visiting scholar at Columbia College and writer of “Christians Towards Christianity: How Proper-Wing Evangelicals are Destroying Our Nation and Our Religion.” “What we should always see is a coordinated response by Christian leaders to counteract this Christian blasphemy.”

Amanda Tyler, govt director of the Baptist Joint Committee, advised the gathering that Christian nationalism just isn’t solely exemplified within the riot or the massacres at South Carolina’s Mother Emanuel African Methodist Episcopal Church and Pennsylvania’s Tree of Life synagogue.

“These are terrible and violent lethal examples, and we have to draw consideration to them, however we are able to’t cease there,” she mentioned. “We will’t distance ourselves and say, ‘Effectively, we’re not like that.’ As an alternative, I believe, it behooves us to essentially take a look at what Christian nationalism appears like and have these powerful conversations inside our congregations.”

RELATED: National Council of Churches elects all-female officers, approves NRSV update

Spurred by the occasions of Jan. 6, the Baptist Joint Committee for Spiritual Liberty labored with Vote Frequent Good to publish a free three-session grownup examine curriculum that defines Christian nationalism because the merger of Christianity with American identification. In 2019, the BJC organized a largely liberal-leaning group of Christian thinkers and leaders to place out a declaration referred to as “Christians Towards Christian Nationalism.”

De La Torre mentioned he has discovered that some progressives don’t acknowledge their racist methods.

“I’ve discovered liberal Christians to be at occasions extra racist,” he mentioned, citing some who’ve been dismissive of individuals of coloration or their communities. “And but they don’t know they’re racist as a result of, in spite of everything, they’re liberals.”

The Rev. Jim Bear Jacobs, co-director for racial justice and group engagement for the Minnesota Council of Church buildings, mentioned he agreed with De La Torre’s warning that some progressives don’t acknowledge the affect of white supremacy.

“Being in these realms of white progressive Christian areas is exhausting, for Black and Indigenous individuals and different individuals of coloration,” he mentioned. “And in very actual phrases, it’s a lot simpler to navigate the conservative areas as a result of at the least there, the racism is overt.”

The dialogue got here as new research from Public Faith Analysis Institute discovered that 52% of white evangelical Protestants agreed with the assertion “God meant America to be a brand new promised land the place European Christians might create a society that may very well be an instance to the remainder of the world.”

“I used to be really shocked,” mentioned Yale College sociologist Philip Gorski, regardless of his research of the difficulty. “It’s not solely alive however rising, specifically because it begins to meld with types of white supremacism and white nationalism that was very a lot on the margins of American politics.”

The PRRI examine discovered that 34% of white mainline Protestants and 37% of white Catholics — and 12% of white religiously unaffiliated individuals — agreed with the “promised land” assertion.

A participant within the NCC session requested methods to “lovingly disentangle Christian nationalism” from white individuals like himself who could not acknowledge the affect of this ideology on their Christian religion.

Hendricks beneficial going again to the Bible and speaking about its teachings, such because the Gospel of Luke, which speaks of preaching to the poor and setting free the oppressed.

“It’s so necessary to return to fundamentals and proclaim what we perceive the decision of the gospel to be — to construct a loving and simply and wholesome society and world for all individuals,” he mentioned.

De La Torre and Jacobs prompt that NCC members must deal with the viewpoints of Black, Indigenous and folks of coloration communities to problem their assumptions and broaden their views.

“They should begin shopping for books written by biblical students of coloration, queer students, feminist students, and skim these texts to discover ways to learn the Bible, by way of the eyes of the marginalized of the earth,” De La Torre mentioned. “Not by way of a steady studying of German biblical students who mainly simply reinforces Eurocentric thought and Eurocentric philosophy.”

This story has been up to date.

RELATED: Survey: ‘Great replacement’ belief correlates with Christian nationalist views