Christian NewsToday

Why is the church failing within the West?

(RNS) — There are quite a few indicators that the Catholic Church is failing in Western nations. There are few vocations, church attendance is down and younger persons are leaving the church in droves. There are as many theories explaining this decline as there are commentators, however the theories will be collected in two main baskets: those who blame tradition and those who blame the church itself.

The Catholic hierarchy tends in charge up to date tradition for the church’s issues. Consumerism, individualism and secularism high their listing of detrimental forces. The media bombards folks with photos and messages which can be antithetical to Christianity: Happiness comes from intercourse, cash and energy. Life is just too busy with work and leisure to have time for faith.

The social constructions that supported faith have additionally weakened.

Ethnic neighborhoods that after bolstered non secular communities and values have seen a decline as their residents have been disbursed to the suburbs. As Catholics joined the mainstream, they misplaced their roots. Fewer kids go to Catholic faculties. Interfaith marriages have elevated as younger Catholics socialize with non-Catholics. As they received higher educated, they have been much less prone to comply with the clergy with out questions.

There’s a number of reality on this cultural rationalization for the church’s failings, however blaming the tradition is like blaming the climate. That’s the world we reside in; study to take care of it. Retreating to a Catholic ghetto is just not an choice. 


RELATED: I forgive Pope Benedict. I hope others can too.


The idea that the church itself is in charge for its decline includes a conservative and a liberal model. Each blame the hierarchy for not dealing correctly with the intercourse abuse disaster. Liberals stress the shortage of accountability and lay involvement, whereas conservatives level their fingers at homosexual clergymen.

Conservatives additionally blame the modifications within the church ordered by the Second Vatican Council. Previous to the council, the church was a rock of stability and certainty in a stormy world. Change undermined the credibility of the church as a result of change was an admission that the church was flawed prior to now. One week you’d go to hell for consuming meat on Friday; the subsequent week you have been OK. One yr you have been instructed that the Mass would at all times be in Latin; the subsequent yr it could be in English.

Conservatives additionally blame theologians for complicated the folks by publicly debating ethical and doctrinal issues that the hierarchy says are definitive educating. In addition they imagine that the social justice message of the church distracts from its conventional dogmas. Some argue that ecumenical and interreligious dialogue has led to the assumption that each one religions are equally legitimate. Emphasizing the function of the laity within the church took the priest off his pedestal and made the priesthood much less engaging.

Conservatives imagine Pope Francis goes within the flawed path and pray for a return to the insurance policies of Popes John Paul II and Benedict XVI.

The liberal model, in the meantime, factors the finger on the hierarchy.

Liberals imagine Vatican II was just the start of reforms that have been essential for the church. They imagine the hierarchy, particularly John Paul II, feared chaos within the church and shut down any additional reform. The paperwork of the council have been interpreted by means of a conservative lens, and theologians have been labeled dissidents and silenced if they didn’t toe the Vatican line.

Commentators such because the Rev. Andrew Greeley believed that the hierarchy misplaced the laity when Pope Paul VI reaffirmed the church’s prohibition towards synthetic contraception. The educating was rejected by each ethical theologians and the laity.

Denying Communion to divorced and remarried Catholics has additionally been problematic for {couples} and their kids.

Liberals additionally blame the hierarchy for the vocation disaster as a result of, they argue, there could be loads of clergymen in the event that they have been allowed to marry, and much more if ladies have been permitted ordination.

Liberals additionally argue that the hierarchy’s opposition to abortion and homosexual rights has alienated many individuals, particularly the younger. Folks have additionally been alienated by bishops who deny Communion to sure Democratic politicians.

The liberals say that the hierarchy is following a lot the identical path it took in Europe, the place it alienated the working lessons within the 19th century with its alliance with the higher lessons. For a lot of the 20th century, anti-clericalism was nonexistent in America as a result of the bishops sided with unions and the working lessons. Anti-clericalism solely blossomed when bishops aligned themselves with the Republican Occasion towards abortion and homosexual rights.

As a social scientist, I imagine that the preponderance of proof helps the liberal rationalization of the decline of the church, however I believe that the conservatives make some good factors. Actually, the modifications after Vatican II weren’t effectively defined or carried out. The clergy have been as confused because the laity. And liberals want to elucidate why extra Catholics are becoming a member of evangelical church buildings than liberal church buildings.


RELATED: The lesson for Catholic bishops from Benedict report: Apologize, apologize, apologize


One of many issues with all these theories, nonetheless, is that they have been developed by theologians who imagine that concepts are what encourage people. Concepts are necessary, however expertise typically issues extra.

Plenty of folks keep within the church regardless that they disagree with some church educating. However a nasty expertise in confession, at a marriage or at a funeral can flip folks away for good. Extra persons are pushed away from the church by conceited clergymen than by disagreements over theology. That is why Francis is so vital of clericalism.

And the very fact is, we lose extra folks by means of boredom than due to theology. Now that individuals don’t imagine that they are going to go to hell for lacking Mass on Sunday, they aren’t going to return except they profit from the expertise.

If the preaching is boring, if the music doesn’t transfer them, if they don’t really feel welcomed, then they aren’t going to return again. If the Mass is seen as one thing that the priest does, if the Scriptures are the area of the clergy, if there is no such thing as a sense of neighborhood, then why come?

That is why many Catholics are drawn to evangelical church buildings. Concepts are necessary, however Catholicism should even be a lived expertise that’s related to the lives of the trustworthy. The pre-Vatican II church offered such experiences in common devotions. After Vatican II, the liturgy was supposed to supply this expertise however too typically it didn’t.  

So the subsequent time we’ve got a dialogue of why the church is failing, don’t invite the theologians; invite sociologists, psychologists, artists, musicians and the individuals who have left the church. 

Related Articles

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

Back to top button