Religion NewsToday

‘Nice substitute’ perception correlates with Christian nationalist views

(RNS) — An usually repeated aspect of Christian nationalism — an ideology with a spread of expressions and more and more vocal supporters — is a perception in America’s divine origins. America, proponents insist, is supposed to be a “metropolis on a hill” which God intends as a blessing and instance for the world. 

A brand new survey finds a majority of People who maintain to such a view additionally imagine in a “substitute” conspiracy idea holding that immigrants are invading the U.S. in an try to interchange the nation’s present tradition.

The survey findings had been launched in an editorial on Monday (Oct. 11) by Public Faith Analysis Institute CEO Robert P. Jones. In his submit, which was revealed each on the Substack platform and at Religion News Service, Jones revealed beforehand unpublished knowledge from a broader survey conducted by PRRI in August — particularly, a query regarding a telling of U.S. historical past usually voiced by Christian nationalists.

Requested whether or not “God meant America to be a brand new promised land the place European Christians may create a society that could possibly be an instance to the remainder of the world,” white evangelical Protestants had been the one spiritual group with a majority (52%) who mentioned they fully or principally agree.

Hispanic Protestants had been second (46%), adopted by different nonwhite Protestants (38%), white Catholics (37%), Hispanic Catholics (35%) and white mainliners (34%).

Amongst these least prone to agree had been Jewish People (27%), Black Protestants (26%), different non-Christians (15%) and the religiously unaffiliated (11%).

Jones famous the query echoes the Doctrine of Discovery, a theological precept outlined in a collection of papal bulls that has been used for hundreds of years to justify the subjugation of Indigenous peoples.

“God meant America to be a brand new promised land the place European Christians may create a society that could possibly be an instance to the remainder of the world.” Graphic courtesy of PRRI

A chart accompanying the submit revealed help for the thought is notably increased amongst Republicans (53%) than Democrats (18%), and is very excessive amongst those that belief far-right media sources (67%) and those that imagine conspiracy theories related to the QAnon motion (65%).

Jones additionally pointed to 1 particularly unsettling traits amongst those that fully or principally agree that the U.S. was singled out by the divine: most (55%) imagine the “substitute idea” concept that immigrants are invading the U.S. and “changing our cultural and ethnic background.”

The so-called nice substitute idea is popular among white nationalists, together with racists who chanted slogans linked to the thought through the 2017 clashes in Charlottesville, Virginia. The Anti-Defamation League has additionally argued males who carried out latest mass shootings in a mosque in Christchurch, New Zealand, a synagogue in Pittsburgh and a Walmart in El Paso, Texas, all appeared to both specific sentiment just like the speculation or reference it outright in on-line manifestos.

But the speculation is now pushed by extra mainstream conservative voices, notably Fox Information host Tucker Carlson. He referenced the speculation by title throughout a September episode of his present and accused the Biden administration of attempting to make use of immigration “to alter the racial mixture of the nation.”

Within the PRRI survey, most People who belief Fox Information (52%) agreed that God meant America to be a brand new promised land.

The margin of error for the general survey is +/- 1.86 share factors.

Related Articles

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Back to top button